Blog

Offering 12 weeks of paid parental leave reduces preventable turnover by 69%, yet only 27% of small businesses provide this critical benefit. While many businesses recognize the importance of offering paid parental leave, small business owners in Pennsylvania face unique challenges when trying to implement it. With tighter margins, workforce constraints, and a more localized customer base, the logistical and financial aspects of offering paid leave can seem daunting.

But here’s the reality: paid parental leave isn’t just an employee benefit; it’s a smart business strategy. In Pennsylvania and beyond, companies that offer paid leave see improvements in retention, productivity, and morale, which ultimately help reduce turnover costs and foster a more engaged workforce. This guide focuses on practical, cost-effective strategies and resources for small businesses in Pennsylvania to implement paid parental leave, while also highlighting national models that can work for any small business.

The Business Case for Paid Parental Leave

Retention and Recruitment Benefits

Employee retention is a significant concern for small business owners, especially in Pennsylvania, where businesses are often competing with larger corporations for top talent. Studies show that nearly one in three women who do not have paid leave leave the workforce within the first year of having a baby. The cost of replacing an employee can be significant - ranging from 50% to 200% of their annual salary depending on the role.

Businesses in Pennsylvania that offer paid parental leave often experience lower turnover rates, reducing hiring and training costs. Nationally, employees increasingly prioritize family-friendly policies when deciding where to work. For businesses in the Keystone State looking to retain their workforce, paid leave is one of the most effective tools.

Moreover, a significant majority of workers consider family-friendly benefits, including paid leave, crucial when evaluating job opportunities. For small businesses in Pennsylvania that may not have the same financial resources as large companies, offering paid leave can be a way to stand out in a competitive labor market.

Increased Productivity and Employee Loyalty

Paid leave is not just about attracting and retaining employees; it also fosters a culture of support and trust. Companies that offer paid family leave report an increase in productivity. In Pennsylvania, businesses that create a supportive work environment through paid leave see improvements in employee morale, leading to greater productivity. Employees who feel valued are more likely to be engaged in their work, making them more productive and loyal.

Research from the National Bureau of Economic Research shows that businesses offering paid leave see long-term benefits in terms of employee engagement, efficiency, and overall company performance. In Pennsylvania, small businesses can apply these insights to strengthen their teams and create a more positive workplace.

Competitive Advantage for Small Businesses

While large corporations often dominate discussions about paid parental leave, small businesses in Pennsylvania can use paid leave to differentiate themselves. Only 27% of private-sector workers nationwide have access to paid parental leave, and this number is often even lower in Pennsylvania. By offering this benefit, small businesses can stand out from competitors who do not provide leave, making them more attractive to potential employees.

In 2023, a survey by the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) found that small businesses with strong paid leave policies saw 40% fewer resignations among new parents compared to those without any leave benefits. For small businesses in Pennsylvania, this can lead to more stability and a more loyal workforce.

National and State Models for Paid Parental Leave

Federal Support: Tax Incentives and Credits

The federal government offers several resources to help small businesses manage the costs of paid parental leave. The Employer Credit for Paid Family and Medical Leave (IRC §45S) allows small businesses to claim a tax credit of 12.5% to 25% of wages paid to employees on family leave. This incentive helps offset the financial burden of offering paid leave.

Additionally, the Work Opportunity Tax Credit (WOTC) can help businesses hiring new employees to cover leave absences, especially those from certain target groups. Small businesses in Pennsylvania can take advantage of these federal programs to reduce costs and provide paid leave to their employees.

State-Specific Paid Leave Programs

While Pennsylvania does not currently have a statewide paid parental leave program, there are several state models that offer valuable lessons. States like California, New York, and Massachusetts have implemented successful paid leave programs that can serve as inspiration for businesses in Pennsylvania:

• California: Employees receive up to 60-70% of wages for eight weeks through a state disability fund (California EDD, 2023).
• New York: Offers 12 weeks at 67% pay, fully funded through employee payroll deductions (New York State, 2023).
• Massachusetts: Offers up to 12 weeks of paid family leave, with a maximum weekly benefit of $1,170.64 in 2025. The program is funded through a payroll tax of 0.88% of eligible wages for employers with 25 or more employees, and 0.46% for smaller employers (Bowditch, 2025).

What About Pennsylvania?

While Pennsylvania does not yet have a statewide paid leave program, there are ongoing efforts to make this a reality. SB 580, a bill currently in the Pennsylvania legislature, aims to introduce a statewide paid leave program. Also known as The Family Care Act, this initiative would be a major step toward providing paid parental leave to workers across the state.

For more on Pennsylvania's information on paid leave, visit our page on state-specific paid leave initiatives.

Cost-Effective Strategies for Implementing Paid Parental Leave in Pennsylvania

Small businesses in Pennsylvania can use several strategies to make paid parental leave more affordable and manageable. Here are some tips to help local businesses offer this crucial benefit without breaking the bank.

1. Staffing Solutions to Manage Workload

Managing workloads during an employee's leave can be challenging, but there are affordable solutions available:

• Temp Agencies: Partnering with local staffing firms, like Robert Half or local temp agencies in Pennsylvania, can provide short-term coverage without the long-term commitment.
• Freelancers & Contractors: Platforms like Upwork or Fiverr can connect businesses with qualified freelancers to help manage project-based work during an employee’s leave.
• Cross-Training Employees: Offering cross-training programs for employees can ensure that there are always capable hands to cover critical roles during parental leave.

2. Financial Tools for Affordability

There are several financial tools to help Pennsylvania small businesses provide paid parental leave:

• Tax Credits & Grants: Take full advantage of federal programs like IRC §45S and state-funded incentives if they become available. Pennsylvania businesses can use these to reduce the costs of paid leave.
• Pro-Rata Leave Policies: Consider offering paid leave based on hours worked (e.g., one hour of paid leave per 30 hours worked), making the leave policy more affordable.
• Hybrid Leave Models: Another option is to offer a combination of paid and unpaid leave, such as 4 weeks of full pay plus 4 weeks of unpaid leave, allowing employees to supplement their income with disability insurance.

3. Phased Implementation Approach

Small businesses can take a phased approach to implementing paid parental leave, which makes the transition easier:

• Year 1: Start with 6 weeks of leave at 50% pay for full-time employees.
• Year 3: Expand to 12 weeks at 70% pay, with options for part-time workers to take leave at reduced rates.
• Flexibility: Stagger leave options, such as offering part-time returns for six months, to accommodate both business needs and employee preferences.

4. Leverage Short-Term Disability Insurance

Short-Term Disability (STD) insurance can be a helpful tool for both employers and employees navigating parental leave, especially for birth mothers who need medical recovery time after childbirth. While not technically a form of “paid parental leave,” STD can cover a portion of an employee’s wages (typically 50–70%) for 6-8 weeks following delivery, depending on the policy and type of birth.

In Pennsylvania, STD insurance is not state-mandated, so it’s usually offered through a private plan that an employer may choose to provide or facilitate. Businesses that offer STD as part of their benefits package make it easier for employees to combine medical leave (via STD) with bonding time through a broader paid parental leave policy.

Employers can structure leave policies to align with STD coverage. For example, employers could cover 6 weeks through STD and then offer an additional 6 weeks of employer-paid or unpaid bonding leave. Even if an employer doesn’t directly offer STD, HR teams can provide guidance to help employees explore private options or understand how STD interacts with leave timelines and pay.

Offering or supporting STD coverage creates a more compassionate and medically supportive leave experience for growing families.

Addressing Common Concerns

"We're too small."

It's true that smaller businesses often have tighter margins and fewer backup resources. But being small also means you're more agile - and can implement creative, flexible solutions that meet your team's needs without requiring a corporate-sized budget. A phased approach (starting with partial pay or fewer weeks) and leveraging federal tax credits like IRC §45S can make offering some level of paid leave more attainable. Plus, even a modest leave policy can set you apart from competitors and help retain valued employees — which saves you money in the long run.

"It's too expensive."

Offering paid leave does come with upfront costs - but so does turnover. Replacing an employee can cost up to 200% of their salary, especially for skilled roles. Paid leave helps you keep experienced employees, avoid hiring and training costs, and improve productivity and morale. Tools like the Employer Credit for Paid Family and Medical Leave, along with future state initiatives, can ease the burden. Some businesses also spread out the cost through shared employee contributions or pro-rated accrual policies to make leave more affordable.

"What if my employees won't come back after taking so much time off?"

Data shows that employees are actually more likely to return to work after paid parental leave. In fact, studies have found that 94% of employees who took paid leave came back to their jobs, compared to 77% who didn't have access to paid leave. The opportunity to take time off during such a critical life event builds loyalty and trust - and increases the likelihood that parents will return and stay with your company long term. Additionally, employers can also share resources like our Return from Maternity Leave Guide to help new parents feel more confident and supported as they transition back to work

"Temps are unreliable."

It can be tough to find temporary staff who match your team's experience and culture. However, many small businesses successfully use local staffing agencies, trusted freelancers, or cross-trained internal staff to fill short-term gaps. Planning ahead - such as building a coverage plan into your leave policy - helps ensure business continuity. Many businesses also find that investing in flexibility and communication leads to smoother transitions, even with temporary or part-time help.

"How will this affect our company's workflow and productivity?"

In the short term, the absence of an employee may require adjustments, but the long-term benefits often outweigh the initial disruption. By planning ahead with cross-training and temporary coverage, businesses can manage workflows more efficiently. Additionally, offering paid parental leave can lead to improved employee morale and productivity when they return, as employees appreciate the support and flexibility, leading to higher engagement and performance. Consider offering tools like our Return from Maternity Leave Guide to help employees plan and communicate their needs for returning to work.

"What if paid parental leave creates a disparity between full-time and part-time employees?"

To address concerns about fairness, consider creating a leave policy that accommodates both full-time and part-time employees in proportion to their work hours. For instance, part-time workers could receive a reduced amount of paid leave based on their hours worked. Ensuring that your paid leave policy is inclusive of all employees will help maintain a sense of fairness while supporting those who need it.

"What if I can't offer paid parental leave right away?"

It's okay to start small. Consider offering a phased approach to paid parental leave that increases over time. This allows you to gradually implement the benefit while managing your finances and staffing needs. Many businesses start by offering a few weeks of paid leave and then increase the benefit as the company grows. You can also offer hybrid models with a mix of paid and unpaid leave to reduce the financial burden.

Parental Leave: Frequently Asked Questions

Why should parents get paid parental leave?

Paid parental leave allows new parents to care for and bond with their child during the critical first weeks of life. It improves long-term outcomes for both children and parents while reducing stress, health complications, and financial strain. For employers, it supports workforce stability and improves employee retention.

Should companies have to provide paid parental leave?

Many experts and advocacy groups, including Investments in Caring PA, believe that providing paid parental leave is a shared responsibility that benefits society, businesses, and families. While mandates are debated, offering leave helps employers attract talent and demonstrates a commitment to workforce well-being.

What are the business benefits of offering paid parental leave?

Businesses that offer paid leave often experience lower turnover, improved employee morale, higher productivity, and stronger recruitment results. It also signals that a company supports work-life balance, which is increasingly important to today’s workforce.

How can small businesses afford to offer paid parental leave?

Small businesses can use strategies like phased rollouts, hybrid paid/unpaid models, federal tax credits (like IRC §45S), and temporary staffing solutions. Investments in Caring PA provides tools and guidance to help small businesses implement sustainable leave policies.

How do I start building a paid parental leave policy?

Start with a clear assessment of your current benefits and budget. Consult legal and HR experts, explore example policies from similar organizations, and use resources like our Paid Leave page to find templates, funding strategies, and phased implementation ideas tailored for Pennsylvania businesses.

What is the ideal length of paid parental leave?

Research suggests that 12 weeks is the ideal minimum to allow for proper recovery and bonding. Longer leaves (up to 16 weeks) provide additional health and developmental benefits. Some companies use a phased return to work for added flexibility.

Should fathers get paternity leave?

Yes. Fathers play a critical role in early child development and family support. Offering paternity leave helps promote gender equity, reduces pressure on mothers, and leads to better outcomes for families overall.

Can paid parental leave be offered to all caregivers, not just parents?

Absolutely. Many companies now include caregiving leave for employees supporting aging parents or ill family members. These inclusive policies reflect modern caregiving responsibilities and help employees stay productive while managing life’s challenges.

Is paid parental leave discriminatory?

No, when designed and implemented equitably, paid parental leave is not discriminatory. In fact, it's a way to create more equitable workplaces by ensuring all employees, regardless of gender, caregiving role, or income level, have the opportunity to care for their families.

What are the negative effects of paid parental leave?

When poorly planned, some businesses may experience short-term staffing challenges or budget constraints. However, with proper planning, cross-training, and use of external resources, these challenges can be minimized and outweighed by long-term gains in productivity and retention.

Which country has the best parental leave?

Countries like Sweden, Norway, and Estonia are known for generous, well-structured parental leave programs. While the U.S. lags behind, Pennsylvania businesses can still build strong leave policies by learning from these global models and adapting best practices locally.

What's Next?

Providing paid parental leave isn't just about compliance - it's about investing in your workforce and building a resilient, loyal team. For small businesses in Pennsylvania, cost concerns are valid, but there are numerous strategies, tax incentives, and resources available to make it work. Whether leveraging state initiatives, structuring phased rollouts, or tapping into external resources, businesses can provide the support working parents need while reaping the rewards of improved retention and productivity.

For more resources and information about Pennsylvania-specific initiatives, visit Investments in Caring PA. And, if you’re an employee preparing to return to work after parental leave, check out our Return from Maternity Leave Guide, filled with tips, tools, and support to help you navigate your transition with confidence.